Friday, 31 December 2004
American Generosity
In a recent Yahoo news article U.N. Emergency Relief Coordinator Jan Egeland called the United States stingy in its relief aid. Of course the MSM loves this story because they get to blame America first for all of the ills in the world.
Captain's Quarter puts the claim of stinginess to rest by reporting on the actual contributions of each nation in the effort to the clean up Asia after the tsunami disaster.
It was the final paragraph of the article that illustrates the true bias of the MSM.
Among the world's two dozen wealthiest countries, the United States often is among the lowest in donors per capita for official development assistance worldwide, even though the totals are larger. According to the Paris-based Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development of 30 wealthy nations, the United States gives the least -- at 0.14 percent of its gross national product, compared with Norway, which gives the most at 0.92 percent.
The first thing I wanted to know was how much money the US gave in real dollars versus Norway. After going to the CIA's web site to find out the GDP of both countries we find out that the Norway government gave $1.5 billion dollars in aid. The United States gave over $15 billion dollars in aid. Even though we give a smaller percentage of GDP, we are giving ten times the money.
My next step was to search the web to find out how much private donations Americans gives to foreign countries. In my search I came across a compelling article by the Hudson Institute from 2003.
The main thrust of the article points to the ridiculousness of counting only government aid when looking at a countries generosity. It overlooks all of the contributions that are made from private sources. This is important because countries that give a greater portion of the GDP give very little in private donations. On the other hand the United States gives many times more in private donations than government aid.
The only difficulty in determining the amount of private cheddar going tp foreign aid. The article outlines some of the sources for private aid to foreign countries.
- Church donations go to fund many world wide efforts for helping feed and clothe people. It is difficult to track down how much is actually donated.
- Business's set up foundations to provide aid to countries around the world. As companies become more international they also provide help to the local areas where they operate.
- Another source of foreign aid is the growing amount of investment capital that is going to other countries to help develop entrepreneurial spirit in underdeveloped countries
- University provide billions of dollars in aid for students who wish to come to the United States to study.
- Another statistic that is not covered is the remittance returned to families in foreign countries. The United States provide much greater remittance than any other country in the world. Heck it is the number two source of revenue for Mexico.
- Also not counted is the amount of research and development that trickles down to third world countries in the form of better medicine, better methods for raising crops, and other technological advances that can help developing countries accelerate growth.
At first glance, America does look stingy compared to other countries, but once you start to do research on the subject you find that America is by far the most generous nation in the world. We just provide it in true American spirit. Not through the government but through private entrepreneurial initiatives. The information I researched could have easily been discovered by the writer of the article, but he would rather blame American than tell the whole story.
NOTE: I also found an article from Tech Central Station that outlines $34 Billion dollars that are sent overseas from private sources in the US.